Dallas Cowboys free company: Selecting one of the best mixture of gamers to re-sign

Only one week into March, the Dallas Cowboys have already had a extra productive offseason than they did in the course of the spring of 2024. Dallas signed their largest impending free agent, Osa Odighizuwa, to a multi-year deal and are rumored to be trying into locking up extra of their very own gamers.

Whereas the Cowboys have gotten off to a comparatively good begin, there’s nonetheless loads of work to be carried out to change into a playoff-caliber group. With that in thoughts, at the moment, we play an offseason model of this or that, selecting between two doable paths for Dallas this spring.

Tell us for those who agree with our choices within the feedback part.

Photograph by Cooper Neill/Getty Pictures

This – Re-sign Jourdan Lewis AND Cooper Rush
or
That – Re-Signal Rico Dowdle AND Chauncey Golston

Our verdict…

Jess Haynie

I’ll take the Lewis/Rush state of affairs due to all 4 gamers listed, Lewis is one of the best and hardest to switch. We might have already got the subsequent Golston in Marshawn Kneeland, and whereas Dowdle is pricey to my coronary heart he’s a median again in a really saturated market. Rush is a pleasant bonus within the deal as a result of I do assume he’s within the higher half of backup QBs. However the huge swing issue right here is Lewis, who pushes the secondary to a different stage of safety and brings veteran management with it.

David Howman

Give me JLew coming again to the group. I actually would miss Chauncey and Rico, however it is a deep draft class at each spots. Jourdan Lewis has quietly been one of the vital constant slot corners within the NFL all through his profession and he brings elite management to the locker room. Additionally, Cooper Rush simply proved why he’s one of many high backup QBs on the market, so bringing him again is a plus

Matt Holleran

As tempting because the package deal of Dowdle and Golston is, I’m taking Lewis and Rush on this one. Cornerback is sneakily one of many weakest place teams on Dallas’ complete roster, and letting their greatest cowl nook from final 12 months stroll in free company looks as if a horrible concept. Lewis means a lot to the Cowboys, not simply on the sphere however within the locker room, that you should convey him again. Whereas retaining Cooper Rush isn’t an attractive transfer, he did show final season that he’s top-of-the-line backup QBs within the league, making him helpful.

Photograph by Sean M. Haffey/Getty Pictures

This – Commerce a 2025 fifth-round + 2026 fourth-round decide for veteran WR Cooper Kupp
or
That – Choose a large receiver with the twelfth total decide

Our verdict…

Jess Haynie

I’m not giving up two draft property, particularly the fourth, for a man who hasn’t performed greater than 12 video games since 2021. A wholesome Kupp can be a killer complement to Lamb, however I don’t assume he may give you that anymore. We have been capable of get Stephon Gilmore and Brandin Cooks for much less in these trades. I’d a lot quite hope {that a} Tet McMillan or Luther Burden (assuming that’s who we’d take within the 1st) lives as much as the hype and provides you a cheap WR2 for the subsequent 4-5 years whilst you’re paying Lamb’s huge contract.

David Howman

I struggled with this one, however in the end I’ll take the first-round receiver over Kupp. I feel that’s the place Dallas ought to go regardless, and both Tetairoa McMillan or Luther Burden can be wonderful additions to this offense for the foreseeable future. Whereas I would like Kupp, his age and harm historical past got here into play right here; in a vacuum I’d be nice with that price ticket, however a rookie WR at 12 goes to supply related manufacturing in 2025 with a a lot increased ceiling.

Matt Holleran

It is a very shut name in my thoughts. In the long run, I’d take sending the commerce package deal for Cooper Kupp over choosing a large receiver with the twelfth total decide. The Cowboys want an instantaneous impression on their offense. Nearly as good because the vast receiver choices are within the first spherical of this draft, there’s no assure they’ll have the ability to come into the league and produce tight away. Whereas Kupp does include some critical well being issues, if he’s on the sphere he’s going to provide at a excessive stage. I’d quite purchase a veteran vast receiver, like Kupp, who can function your quantity two after which choose a high-upside wideout within the third spherical than decide one along with your first-round choice.

Kara Durrette/Getty Pictures

This – Signal a Professional Bowl-caliber offensive participant in free company
or
That – Signal a Professional Bowl-caliber defensive participant in free company

Our verdict…

Jess Haynie

Effectively, Dallas sort of already did “That” after they re-signed Osa Odighizuwa. He’s a borderline Professional Bowler at DT for those who have a look at numbers in comparison with those that did get acknowledged. However that apart, I’d be glad in the event that they made an enormous transfer at both WR or O-Line to take extra strain off the draft. Barring a commerce down for extra picks, it’s going to be exhausting for Dallas to deal with all of its wants. I’d hate to see them move on a superior expertise at a place to allow them to fill a roster want elsewhere, which regularly results in reaching.

David Howman

¿Por que no los dos? In a super world, the Cowboys do each. In any case, they’ve sufficient cap area now. However since I’ve to choose one, give me a Professional Bowl offensive participant. That is nonetheless an offense first league and one of the best ways to win is to attain extra factors. Plus, Micah Parsons alone is value three Professional Bowl gamers in my thoughts.

Matt Holleran

With the restructures of CeeDee Lamb and Dak Prescott, the Cowboys have the cap area and adaptability to signal Professional Bowl-caliber gamers on each side of the ball. Whereas that’s the dream state of affairs, including only one appears extra real looking. If I needed to decide, I’d need to add an offensive participant. I imagine Dallas’ primary precedence this offseason must be getting Dak Prescott again to enjoying at an MVP-caliber stage. Giving him a Professional Bowl-level participant on the offensive line or at vast receiver would drastically improve the possibilities Prescott is again to his classic self in 2025.