We requested a handful of soccer pundits to provide us their perspective on Toronto FC’s $7 million per yr signee, Italian midfielder Sebastian Giovinco. Oh, and we made them do it in 100 phrases or much less.
BY
numerous
Posted
January 21, 2015
3:13 PM
SHARE THIS STORY
Mark Zeigler, San Diego Union-Tribune
As fascinating because the particulars of Sebastian Giovinco’s document contract is the timing, simply days earlier than the expiration of the league’s collective bargaining settlement with its gamers. MLS deputy commissioner Mark Abbott has been telling people who the league, its golf equipment, and advertising and marketing arm nonetheless lose greater than $100 million yearly—little doubt a negotiating tactic to protect the single-entity system that has stored the minimal wage at $36,504. However in case you’re shedding a lot cash, why is a membership that has by no means certified for the MLS playoffs forking over $35 million-plus over the subsequent 5 years on a five-foot-five Italian midfielder? Can’t have it each methods.
Brian Sciaretta, ASN contributing editor
In a transfer that dwarfed signing Jozy Altidore, Toronto FC signed Giovinco to a blockbuster deal that can make him the world’s highest paid Italian participant. It bucks the stereotype that solely European stars on the tail finish of their careers make their technique to MLS and that’s good—but it surely comes at a value. Toronto is overpaying for expertise and buying related stars will now show harder as related gamers will search related cash. On the sector, after a catastrophe in 2014, all expectations can be on Toronto to not simply make the playoffs however go far as properly.
Kristan Heneage, soccer author
Giovinco is an effective participant with one deadly flaw: He’s 6kgs lighter and one inch shorter than Messi.
Travis Clark, TopDrawerSoccer.com
On the floor, there’s a lot to be enthusiastic about Giovinco. An skilled participant, coming from a giant European membership, simply 27 years
previous. However it’s a development that is turning into worrisome in MLS: the wage hole between the best and lowest earners on the squad. And wildly
overpaying to lure gamers from Europe would not appear sustainable for a league that cries poverty at each flip. Growth, whereas much less buzzworthy, must be the pillar MLS continues to construct on, with Giovinco-like signings few and much between.
Jon Arnold, Objective.com (and ASN now and again)
There are not any game-changers any extra, however maybe there are trailblazers. This does not sign that different nation’s internationals are going to flood MLS making large cash, but it surely opens the door to it taking place extra typically. Extra internationals, larger high quality. Increased high quality, larger TV rankings. Increased TV rankings, extra money. More cash, MLS reaches one among world’s prime leagues by 2022. It is not that straightforward and Giovinco’s arrival would not safe any of that—but it surely does make that path extra possible.
Brooke Tunstall, ASN contributing editor
We needs to be extra enthusiastic about this. For years, MLS followers have wished the league to spend the cash wanted to nab high-end European nationwide teamers of their prime. Properly, Giovinco is 27 and was on Italy’s squad at Euro 2012 and the Confederations Cup two summers in the past. That’s pretty much as good a pedigree for a overseas participant his age as MLS has ever seen. He ought to slot in very properly with Toronto, taking part in between Altidore and Bradley, forming a deadly triangle. After all, it’s TFC so we’re all ready to see how they screw it up, however this signing remains to be a giant deal for MLS.
Will Parchman, TopDrawerSoccer.com
From a soccer standpoint, Giovinco makes lots of sense in Toronto. TFC by no means actually addressed its urgent want for a No. 10 in 2014, and the overloaded midfield confirmed the pressure. This could free Bradley to remain a bit deeper and launch Altidore, who will profit from higher service than he ever had at Sunderland. However from a financial perspective? A bit shakier. This can be a lot of money for a man who’s performed sparingly this season and is presumably off form. Higher hope he regains it rapidly.
Nick Kariuki, ASN contributor
The Giovinco signing feels just like final season’s deal for Defoe. Whereas Juventus is the next caliber crew than Spurs, each confirmed purpose scorers have been struggling for important taking part in time. Beating the European golf equipment that have been linked with the Italian is definitely spectacular however Vanney and Toronto now have to guarantee that within the three months earlier than the Italian arrives they arrange a squad and system the place he’s a contributing issue to the crew’s first playoff run, not the carrying pressure. For a begin, Altidore might want to shake his funk and Bradley wants defensive assist.
John Godfrey, ASN editor in chief
Determined instances name for determined measures, and shelling out $35 million for Giovinco tells me that Toronto FC GM Tim Bezbatchenko is aware of full properly that his employment standing and status are formally in danger. The previous MLS government made all of the improper strikes final yr, overspending on stars whereas leaving gaping holes within the lineup. Is he doing the identical this season? Presumably. If TFC misses the playoffs but once more, count on entrance workplace modifications—but once more.
Now it is your flip, soccer followers. What does the Giovinco signing imply to you? (100 phrases or much less, please.)
