Rating the Giants’ choices at quarterback in 2025

The highest precedence for the New York Giants this offseason is to construct again their quarterback room.

They at the moment should not have any quarterbacks underneath contract for the 2025 season and will probably be looking for so as to add at the least three to their preseason 90-man roster this spring and summer season.

Who these gamers might be is anybody’s guess. They maintain the No. 3 general decide within the 2025 NFL draft and can have almost $60 million in obtainable cap area come March, so they may have loads of ammunition so as to add a starter, a good backup, and a doable future face of the franchise.

Common supervisor Joe Schoen talked about in his season-ending press convention that he want to convey again Tommy DeVito, who’s an unique rights free agent. However he’s a third-string emergency possibility on this league. In addition they may re-add Drew Lock and/or Tim Boyle in a pinch as they’re acquainted with the offense.

It’s not going that the Giants become involved within the Sam Darnold free agent derby except they’ll get him at a reduction. Quarterbacks aren’t low cost lately, nevertheless, and there may be some group on the market that’s going to overpay.

Listed below are another choices at quarterback they may take into account this offseason.

Jeffrey Becker-USA TODAY Sports activities

As famous above, this appears unlikely. Regardless of Darnold ending the season with two vital stinkers, he’s arguably the highest quarterback obtainable coming off a career-best season. With restricted free agent choices, loads of groups will probably be out there for him.

If a bidding struggle ensues, his worth will seemingly skyrocket and the Giants merely can’t afford to overpay for a bridge quarterback. Past that, Darnold will attempt to keep away from that state of affairs in quest of a long-term deal.

The Giants will in all probability dip their toe into the Darnold waters however don’t count on it to go wherever.

Chris Graythen/Getty Pictures

Yearly through the pre-draft course of, a participant emerges on the NFL Mix or professional days. There might be a quarterback or two that bolsters their draft inventory within the underwear Olympics that catches the Giants’ eye. There are gamers they wouldn’t take into account excessive within the first spherical however on Days 2 and three.

There’s a gaggle that has that potential: Texas’ Quinn Ewers, Jaxson Dart of Ole Miss, and Will Howard of Ohio State to call a number of.

Mike Stobe/Getty Pictures

Wanna break the web? Right here’s a simple method to do it. The Giants must pivot a number of occasions of their pondering for this to occur. They would wish their very own air site visitors controller over MetLife Stadium in the event that they made this transfer.

Aaron Rodgers is 40, semi-washed, and costly. The Jets introduced him in as a result of they felt he might be the ultimate piece of a contending roster. The Giants aren’t wherever close to rivalry for the time being and the addition of Rodgers — exterior of prolonging many a media profession — serves little goal right here aside from being a one-year bridge.

Elsa/Getty Pictures

That is based mostly solely on the belief that the Saints launch Derek Carr, which is starting to look prefer it’s solely doable.

Signing Carr as a bridge can be a smart transfer. He gained’t value a lot and might truly proper a ship that merely wants some stability underneath middle. That being mentioned, he’s been very inconsistent himself not too long ago.

However, he’s nonetheless solely 34, and, if he can keep wholesome, can be an asset for a group grooming a younger participant at quarterback.

Ken Blaze-Imagn Pictures

There’ll seemingly be a number of tiers within the quarterback market this offseason, topped by the aforementioned Darnold. Someplace in the course of all that will probably be cost-effective veterans who would play bridge or function a powerful backup with expertise.

A few of these choices will embody Teddy Bridgewater, Carson Wentz, Cooper Rush, Jimmy Garoppolo, Joe Flacco, and Jameis Winston, amongst others.

None of those quarterbacks scream, “That’s the answer!” Nonetheless, they’re serviceable choices that can seemingly be reasonably priced.

Of the group, Winston represents essentially the most intriguing title. He’s a boom-or-bust participant who will at the least take dangers down the sphere and make the Giants’ offense extra dynamic. However he could also be too turnover-prone for Daboll’s liking.

Andy Lyons/Getty Pictures

Mac Jones seemingly gained’t be again with the Jaguars, so he will probably be obtainable. Like Wilson, he had a tough go to date in his profession and might be broken items. He’s a greater possibility however a lesser expertise. No group can have a look at Jones and imagine he’s their long-term reply.

Jones might be an asset as a backup, although. The Giants have loads of backup choices in entrance of them and it’s a spot they’ll want to handle.

Ron Chenoy-Imagn Pictures

For those who’re going to think about Fields, you might as effectively scour the marketplace for different first-round failures like Zach Wilson. Big followers would lose it in the event that they introduced this child in however, as now we have seen, some gamers take a bit longer for the sunshine to go on.

Wilson was a large number with the Jets, primarily as a result of the Jets have been a large number and he was too younger for the highlight. He was rescued by Sean Payton and the Broncos this yr and has had a while to reset his profession. He nonetheless has a cannon for an arm and is simply 25. Put him in the suitable scenario and he may pop.

I can’t be the one one pondering this. This might be a flyer-type, low-risk signing that might work.

Emilee Chinn/Getty Pictures

Andy Dalton hasn’t been related shortly and there’s no actual upside aside from to make use of him as a bridge to get to your subsequent franchise quarterback. If the Giants introduced him in for every other purpose, you’d should query their competency.

Dalton, 37, has had his ups and downs on this league and can be a pleasant mentor for a younger quarterback like he was for Bryce Younger in Carolina.

Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Pictures

The Giants gained’t take Jalen Milroe at No. 3 however reasonably at No. 34, the second decide in Spherical 2. Meaning they’ll both deal the No. 3 decide or maybe take Colorado two-way sensation Travis Hunter there.

This may be the perfect of all worlds in the long run for the Giants as they’ll accumulate some extra expertise and nonetheless have a good QB room ought to they add a veteran alongside the drafting of Milroe.

Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports activities

Identical deal as Ward. Shedeur Sanders could not make it to No. 3. If he does, the Giants should take an extended look. If something, he’ll draw fan curiosity on the very least. The Giants will seemingly usher in a veteran to carry the door for any rookie, so there gained’t be a ton of stress on him.

Sam Navarro-Imagn Pictures

With the 2 groups deciding on earlier than them (Tennessee and Cleveland) out there for quarterbacks, Cam Ward isn’t prone to fall to No. 3. If he does, the Giants should seize him no matter what plans they’d already made.

Matt Krohn-Imagn Pictures

Once more, you’re not marrying the man. Simply bringing him in like they did Kurt Warner again in 2004. Kirk Cousins must be obtainable for very low cost as a result of he carries a base wage of $27.5 million for 2025.

Cousins might be excellent or very dangerous relying on what you’re used to at quarterback. The Giants haven’t gotten a lot out of their quarterbacks the previous few years, so he’s an improve. After all, they’d do that along with including a rookie to their roster.

Barry Reeger-Imagn Pictures

Both Russell Wilson or Justin Fields, each impending free brokers, will probably be out in Pittsburgh this offseason, probably each. The Giants want an skilled quarterback to line up underneath middle in Week 1. Each of those guys can try this and be efficient in a Brian Daboll offense that accommodates an thrilling core of younger weapons (Malik Nabers, Wan’Dale Robinson, Theo Johnson, Tyrone Tracy Jr.).

After all, this is able to be along with the arrival of a rookie quarterback they plan on growing.