Deadzone Eagles Debate: Which Tremendous Bowl victory was higher?

Let’s face it. As soon as the NFL Draft is within the rear view mirror, the calendar of occasions sort of screeches to a halt.

However summer time is a good time of yr for soccer debates. There isn’t any scarcity of points to be contemplated over and mentioned relating to your Birds, so for subsequent few weeks, I’m introducing “The Deadzone Debates.”

Every week I’ll pose a subject for debate and attempt to present stable arguments for both sides. Within the feedback part, you’ll be able to reply with what you assume.

This week, I’ll dive right into a topic I used to be serious about once I went into my garments drawer final week, pulled on my Eagles Tremendous Bowl LIX Champions T-shirt after which placed on my Eagles Tremendous Bowl LII sweatshirt over high of it.

Which Eagles Tremendous Bowl title is the most effective? Which is your favourite?

Each present compelling causes.

Tremendous Bowl 52: Eagles 42, Patriots 37

The primary time is at all times the sweetest. After 51 Tremendous Bowls and 57 years since their final title in 1960, the Eagles have been lastly champions of the NFL. Generations of followers lastly obtained their long-waited-for want. Many people lived by some very, very darkish occasions to get there, and plenty of Birds followers handed earlier than witnessing it. Nevertheless it truly occurred. It’s robust to beat that feeling.The sport featured among the most legendary performs in NFL historical past. The Philly Particular, not solely immortalized in Eagles historical past, is etched into the very lore of the game. However you even have Zach Ertz’ go-ahead landing and, in fact, Brandon Graham’s strip sack of Tom Brady. Three legendary moments in a single recreation. Once more, exhausting to beat.It was a real Philadelphia underdog story. Dropping Carson Wentz, the presumptive NFL MVP, a month earlier than the top of the season felt like a crippling and devastating blow that will torpedo their possibilities of successful all of it. Nick Foles? Have been we actually anticipated to consider he may pull off a Tremendous Bowl run? To be the No. 1 seed within the NFC and but be underdogs in each spherical of the playoffs was about as pure a storyline as a Philly sports activities fan may dream of.They beat Tom Brady and Invoice Belichick, breaking the center of a dynasty. Brady performed maybe his finest total recreation within the Tremendous Bowl that night time, proper up till he fumbled the ball with simply over two minutes left within the recreation. It’s the loss he remembers most in his profession, and isn’t it good that the Philadelphia Eagles lease that room inside his head?Doug Pederson outcoached Belichick. It’s actually that straightforward, and it stays a staggering accomplishment. Pederson set the pattern that’s now commonplace within the NFL, being extremely aggressive on fourth down conditions. He was a unicorn on the time, although.It was an action-packed, back-and-forth contest that went all the way down to the ultimate play, a Hail Mary into the top zone that was nearer to being accomplished than it ought to have been. Nonetheless, the adrenaline was pumping till that cathartic remaining second ticked off the clock.

Tremendous Bowl 59: Eagles 40, Chiefs 22

Not like Tremendous Bowl 52, which was their first look in “the big game” in 13 years, Tremendous Bowl 59 welcomed the Eagles again for the second time in three seasons. The Eagles knew they belonged on this spot, and it felt like, for as soon as, we have been the constructing dynasty.This was no underdog story. This was the story of a terrific staff pushed by revenge, pushed by their crushing defeat two seasons earlier by the hands of the exact same Chiefs. For the primary time in our lives, your Eagles have been the NFL’s elite staff, the staff everybody hates, and yeah, that feels fairly good.Whereas Tremendous Bowl 52 featured an unreal efficiency by the offense and Nick Foles, the protection performed dreadfully towards New England that night time (proper up till the Patriots’ remaining two possessions, anyway). In 59, the protection was the story. To so completely dominate and destroy a Kansas Metropolis staff led by one of many best QBs in NFL historical past was stunning. Give it some thought. Regardless of beating Tom Brady seven years earlier, Brady had his method with the Philly protection in 52. Not so for Mahomes in 59. It was an amazing pleasure watching the ferocious move rush maul and abuse Mahomes for 4 stable quarters, making him appear like Daniel Jones in a method no different protection had ever finished earlier than.Whereas 52 was a detailed recreation that got here all the way down to the ultimate second, 59 was a blowout. In your complete life, did you ever assume you’d dwell to see the Philadelphia Eagles play in a Tremendous Bowl by which they led 40-6??? Towards one of many best offenses, quarterbacks and head coaches the league has ever seen?This recreation additionally featured an amazing variety of memorable performs. Cooper DeJean’s Decide-6 will dwell endlessly in Eagles’ lore. 52 had the Philly Particular. 59 had The Dagger. One play confirmed shock and audacity by Pederson and Foles. The Dagger, nonetheless, was a curb stomping second of pure ecstasy. It could be my favourite second in Eagles historical past, to be trustworthy.Jalen Hurts received the Tremendous Bowl MVP award he ought to have received two years earlier by taking part in one of the crucial full video games a QB has ever performed in Tremendous Bowl historical past. It wasn’t a dominating efficiency, and positively there have been video games the place QBs put up larger numbers. However in each method potential, Hurts owned the competition from begin to end. It additionally introduced full circle his comeback from their hellish defeat two seasons earlier.If you happen to select this recreation, it’s as a result of whereas 52 was a tense-turned-euphoric second of pure civic reduction and pleasure, no Philadelphian may ever have dreamed they’d win a Tremendous Bowl in such dominating vogue. Yeah, there wasn’t a lot drama in 59, and that’s what made it particular. The Eagles put their stamp on their best total season in franchise historical past, and positioned itself among the many best single-season groups in NFL historical past.

So, what’s your alternative?

Which Eagles Tremendous Bowl victory was higher?

Cannot consider we dwell in a actuality the place I can ask this query. #blessed

Closes in 3 days • 139 whole votesView outcomes

Tremendous Bowl LII (Eagles-Pats)Tremendous Bowl LIX (Eagles-Chiefs)Rec 2CommentsThin Stroke Remark Icon BubbleReplyRead 15 replies